Large Location Icon

537 W Prospect Ave; Appleton, WI Property Details

537 W Prospect Ave, Appleton, WI is a Single Family that was built in 1865. This property is not for sale. Our records show that 537 W Prospect Ave has 5 bedrooms, and 2.5 bathrooms, and a total of 2,726 square feet. The lot size of 537 W Prospect Ave is 15,943 square feet.

Off market
537 W Prospect Ave Appleton, WI 54911
$344,900 Estimated Value
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
2,726 SqFt
Property Details

Summary

  • Purchase Method: Cash
  • Owners / Type: 1 / Corporate
  • Owner Status: Corporate
  • Year Built: 1865
  • Purchase Price: $330,000
  • Est. Equity / %: $387,000 / 100%
  • Gross Yield: 9.305%
  • APN: 31-3-0360-00
  • Situs County: Outagamie
  • Length Of Ownership: 1 year, 9 months

Rooms

  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Bathrooms: 2.5
  • Full Bathrooms: 2
  • Total Rooms: 11
  • Partial Bathrooms: 1

Structure

  • Stories: 2
  • Exterior Wall Type: Brick

Measurements

  • Total: 2,726/SqFt
  • Lot: 15,943/SqFt
  • Gross: 4,721/SqFt
  • Garage: 352/SqFt
  • Living: 2,726/SqFt
  • Basement: 1,643/SqFt
  • Building: 4,721/SqFt
  • Ground: 1,643/SqFt
  • Garage Unfinished: 352/SqFt
  • Price Per Square Foot: $121.06

Legal Description

  • Description: GRAND CHUTE PLAT 3WD LOT 1 BLK 7 LESS E30FT LESS DOC# 1602278
Building Insights

Land Information

  • Property Type: Single Family
  • Within Flood Zone: True
  • Flood Zone: X / Low/Medium Risk
  • School District: Appleton Area School District
  • Lat / Lon: 44.25471 / -88.4133
  • Subdivision: Grand Chute
  • Property Class: Residential
  • Zoning: R1C
  • County Use Code: G1

Amenities

  • Heating Fuel Type: Oil
  • Plus Four: 6040
  • Bathroom Fixtures: 10
  • Cooling: Yes
  • Fireplaces: 1
  • Garage: Attached Garage
  • Heating: Hot Water
  • Parking: 1

Ownership Info

537 W Prospect Ave has no associated ownership info
537 W Prospect Ave has no associated ownership info.

Taxes

537 W Prospect Ave has 9 associated Taxes items

537 W Prospect Ave, Appleton, WI pays taxes in Outagamie County, WI. The most recent tax assessment records are from 2025 and show that the current assessed value of the property is $344,900. The APN we've located for 537 W Prospect Ave is 31-3-0360-00.

Unlock the full report
Taxes
  • Assessed Value:  $344,900
  • Assessed Year:  2025
  • Assessed County:  Outagamie
  • APN:  31-3-0360-00
  • Assessed Land Value:  54800
  • Tax Amount:  5068.45
  • Tax Year:  2024
  • Market Value:  390500
  • Market Year:  2025

Tax History

537 W Prospect Ave has 13 associated Tax History items
YearAssessed ValueLand ValueImprovement ValueTax AmountChange RateAssessed CRTax Rate
Year 2025 Assessed Value $344,900 Land Value $54,800 Improvement Value $290,100 Tax Amount Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2024 Assessed Value Land Value Improvement Value Tax Amount $5,068.45 Change Rate -0.048577% Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2023 Assessed Value $344,900 Land Value $54,800 Improvement Value $290,100 Tax Amount $5,327.23 Change Rate -0.074263% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.015446%
Year 2022 Assessed Value $274,900 Land Value $42,000 Improvement Value $232,900 Tax Amount $5,754.58 Change Rate +0.009877% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.020933%
Year 2021 Assessed Value $274,900 Land Value $42,000 Improvement Value $232,900 Tax Amount $5,698.3 Change Rate +0.046381% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.020729%
Year 2020 Assessed Value $274,900 Land Value $42,000 Improvement Value $232,900 Tax Amount $5,445.72 Change Rate +0.027746% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.01981%
Year 2019 Assessed Value $274,900 Land Value $42,000 Improvement Value $232,900 Tax Amount $5,298.7 Change Rate +0.106813% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.019275%
Year 2018 Assessed Value $218,300 Land Value $40,600 Improvement Value $177,700 Tax Amount $4,787.35 Change Rate +0.009789% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.02193%
Year 2017 Assessed Value $218,300 Land Value $40,600 Improvement Value $177,700 Tax Amount $4,740.94 Change Rate +0.016614% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.021718%
Year 2016 Assessed Value $218,300 Land Value $40,600 Improvement Value $177,700 Tax Amount $4,663.46 Change Rate -0.014682% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.021363%
Year 2015 Assessed Value $218,300 Land Value $40,600 Improvement Value $177,700 Tax Amount $4,732.95 Change Rate +0.00842% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.021681%
Year 2014 Assessed Value $218,300 Land Value $40,600 Improvement Value $177,700 Tax Amount $4,693.43 Change Rate -0.002067% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.0215%
Year 2013 Assessed Value $218,300 Land Value $36,200 Improvement Value $182,100 Tax Amount $4,703.15 Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.021544%