Large Location Icon

538 W 91st St; Indianapolis, IN Property Details

538 W 91st St, Indianapolis, IN is a Single Family that was built in 1962. This property is not for sale. Our records show that 538 W 91st St has 3 bedrooms, and 1.5 bathrooms, and a total of 2,378 square feet. The lot size of 538 W 91st St is 21,824 square feet.

Off market
538 W 91st St Indianapolis, IN 46260
$493,300 Estimated Value
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
2,378 SqFt
Property Details

Summary

  • Owners / Type: 1 / Individual
  • Owner Status: Individual
  • Year Built: 1962
  • Est. Equity / %: $472,000 / 100%
  • Gross Yield: 9.969%
  • APN: 49-03-15-122-032.000-800
  • Situs County: Marion

Rooms

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 1.5
  • Full Bathrooms: 1
  • Total Rooms: 10
  • Partial Bathrooms: 1

Structure

  • Building Style: Brick
  • Stories: 1
  • Building Condition: Average
  • Building Quality: B
  • Roof Cover Type: Asphalt
  • Sewer Type: Yes
  • Water Source: Yes

Measurements

  • Total: 2,378/SqFt
  • Lot: 21,824/SqFt
  • Gross: 3,598/SqFt
  • Garage: 624/SqFt
  • Living: 2,378/SqFt
  • Basement: 596/SqFt
  • Building: 3,598/SqFt
  • Ground: 2,378/SqFt

Legal Description

  • Description: SPRING HOLLOW SUB L21
Building Insights

Land Information

  • Property Type: Single Family
  • Within Flood Zone: True
  • Flood Zone: X / Low/Medium Risk
  • School District: Washington Township Metropolitan School District
  • Lat / Lon: 39.919937 / -86.16802
  • Subdivision: Spring Hollow Sub
  • Property Class: Residential
  • County Use Code: 510

Amenities

  • Plus Four: 1724
  • Bathroom Fixtures: 10
  • Cooling: Central
  • Fireplaces: 1
  • Garage: Attached Garage
  • Heating: Central
  • Parking: 2

Ownership Info

538 W 91st St has no associated ownership info
538 W 91st St has no associated ownership info.

Taxes

538 W 91st St has 10 associated Taxes items

538 W 91st St, Indianapolis, IN pays taxes in Marion County, IN. The most recent tax assessment records are from 2025 and show that the current assessed value of the property is $493,300. The APN we've located for 538 W 91st St is 49-03-15-122-032.000-800.

Unlock the full report
Taxes
  • Assessed Value:  $493,300
  • Assessed Year:  2025
  • Assessed County:  Marion
  • APN:  49-03-15-122-032.000-800
  • Assessed Land Value:  73700
  • Market Land Value:  73700
  • Tax Amount:  5904.3
  • Tax Year:  2024
  • Market Value:  493300
  • Market Year:  2025

Tax History

538 W 91st St has 12 associated Tax History items
YearAssessed ValueLand ValueImprovement ValueTax AmountChange RateAssessed CRTax Rate
Year 2025 Assessed Value $493,300 Land Value $73,700 Improvement Value $419,600 Tax Amount Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2024 Assessed Value Land Value Improvement Value Tax Amount $5,904.3 Change Rate +0.101997% Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2023 Assessed Value $393,900 Land Value $73,700 Improvement Value $320,200 Tax Amount $5,357.82 Change Rate -0.106819% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.013602%
Year 2022 Assessed Value $393,900 Land Value $73,700 Improvement Value $320,200 Tax Amount $5,998.58 Change Rate +0.248627% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.015229%
Year 2021 Assessed Value $342,700 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $298,500 Tax Amount $4,804.14 Change Rate +0.101008% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.014019%
Year 2020 Assessed Value $342,700 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $298,500 Tax Amount $4,363.4 Change Rate +0.070206% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.012732%
Year 2019 Assessed Value $342,700 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $298,500 Tax Amount $4,077.16 Change Rate -0.013453% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.011897%
Year 2018 Assessed Value $342,700 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $298,500 Tax Amount $4,132.76 Change Rate +0.039657% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.012059%
Year 2017 Assessed Value $334,000 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $289,800 Tax Amount $3,975.12 Change Rate +0.105373% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.011902%
Year 2016 Assessed Value $327,800 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $283,600 Tax Amount $3,596.18 Change Rate +0.014008% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.010971%
Year 2014 Assessed Value $339,900 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $295,700 Tax Amount $3,546.5 Change Rate -0.009025% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.010434%
Year 2013 Assessed Value $339,900 Land Value $44,200 Improvement Value $295,700 Tax Amount $3,578.8 Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.010529%