Large Location Icon

2504 Sutton Ave; Carmel, IN Property Details

2504 Sutton Ave, Carmel, IN is a Single Family that was built in 1996. This property is not for sale. Our records show that 2504 Sutton Ave has 3 bedrooms, and 2.5 bathrooms, and a total of 2,991 square feet. The lot size of 2504 Sutton Ave is 26,136 square feet.

Off market
2504 Sutton Ave Carmel, IN 46032
$574,400 Estimated Value
3 Beds
2.5 Baths
2,991 SqFt
Property Details

Summary

  • Owners / Type: 1 / Individual
  • Owner Status: Individual
  • Year Built: 1996
  • Open Loans / Balance: 4 / $524,758
  • Est. Equity / %: $126,242 / 19.39%
  • Gross Yield: 8.24%
  • APN: 29-13-04-001-071.000-018
  • Situs County: Hamilton

Rooms

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2.5
  • Full Bathrooms: 2
  • Total Rooms: 6
  • Partial Bathrooms: 1

Structure

  • Building Style: Frame
  • Stories: 2
  • Building Condition: Average
  • Building Quality: A
  • Roof Cover Type: Asphalt
  • Sewer Type: None
  • Water Source: None

Measurements

  • Total: 2,991/SqFt
  • Lot: 26,136/SqFt
  • Gross: 5,246/SqFt
  • Garage: 880/SqFt
  • Living: 2,991/SqFt
  • Basement: 1,375/SqFt
  • Building: 5,246/SqFt
  • Ground: 4,366/SqFt
  • Garage Unfinished: 506/SqFt

Legal Description

  • Description: ACREAGE .60, SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 17, RANGE 3, SUTTON PLACE, SECTION 1, LOT 71
Building Insights

Land Information

  • Property Type: Single Family
  • Within Flood Zone: True
  • Flood Zone: X / Low/Medium Risk
  • School District: Carmel Clay Schools
  • Lat / Lon: 39.952694 / -86.199776
  • Subdivision: Sutton Place Section 1
  • Property Class: Residential
  • County Use Code: 510

Amenities

  • Plus Four: 8684
  • Bathroom Fixtures: 11
  • Cooling: Central
  • Fireplaces: 1
  • Garage: Attached Garage
  • Heating: Central
  • Parking: 3

HOA

  • H O A One: $350
  • H O A Amount: $350
  • H O A One Frequency: Semi-Annual
  • H O A One Name: Huntington Chase Homeowners Association Inc
  • H O A One Type: Home Owner Association

Ownership Info

2504 Sutton Ave has no associated ownership info
2504 Sutton Ave has no associated ownership info.

Taxes

2504 Sutton Ave has 10 associated Taxes items

2504 Sutton Ave, Carmel, IN pays taxes in Hamilton County, IN. The most recent tax assessment records are from 2025 and show that the current assessed value of the property is $574,400. The APN we've located for 2504 Sutton Ave is 29-13-04-001-071.000-018.

Unlock the full report
Taxes
  • Assessed Value:  $574,400
  • Assessed Year:  2025
  • Assessed County:  Hamilton
  • APN:  29-13-04-001-071.000-018
  • Assessed Land Value:  150000
  • Market Land Value:  150000
  • Tax Amount:  5815.8
  • Tax Year:  2024
  • Market Value:  574400
  • Market Year:  2025

Tax History

2504 Sutton Ave has 12 associated Tax History items
YearAssessed ValueLand ValueImprovement ValueTax AmountChange RateAssessed CRTax Rate
Year 2025 Assessed Value $574,400 Land Value $150,000 Improvement Value $424,400 Tax Amount Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2024 Assessed Value Land Value Improvement Value Tax Amount $5,815.8 Change Rate +0.259305% Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2023 Assessed Value Land Value Improvement Value Tax Amount $4,618.26 Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2022 Assessed Value $426,100 Land Value $104,700 Improvement Value $321,400 Tax Amount Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2021 Assessed Value $407,900 Land Value $104,700 Improvement Value $303,200 Tax Amount Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2020 Assessed Value $353,600 Land Value $104,700 Improvement Value $248,900 Tax Amount $3,987.32 Change Rate +0.022122% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.011276%
Year 2019 Assessed Value $340,400 Land Value $80,200 Improvement Value $260,200 Tax Amount $3,901.02 Change Rate +0.019043% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.01146%
Year 2018 Assessed Value $340,400 Land Value $80,200 Improvement Value $260,200 Tax Amount $3,828.12 Change Rate +0.027396% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.011246%
Year 2017 Assessed Value $337,100 Land Value $80,200 Improvement Value $256,900 Tax Amount $3,726.04 Change Rate -0.002132% Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.011053%
Year 2016 Assessed Value $346,600 Land Value $80,200 Improvement Value $266,400 Tax Amount $3,734 Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate +0.010773%
Year 2014 Assessed Value $325,600 Land Value $76,500 Improvement Value $249,100 Tax Amount Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate
Year 2012 Assessed Value Land Value Improvement Value Tax Amount $3,510.48 Change Rate Assessed CR Tax Rate